Edmunds: 2022 Subaru BRZ vs. 2022 Mazda MX-5 Miata RF

The mixture of excessive automobile costs and the approaching arrival of upper rates of interest could make it tough to justify spending cash on a automobile primarily meant for enjoyable. However these two fashions can put a giant smile in your face with out crushing your month-to-month funds: the 2022 Mazda MX-5 Miata RF and the 2022 Subaru BRZ.

Subaru has totally redesigned its BRZ sport coupe for 2022. Just like the previous-generation automobile, this new BRZ is small and light-weight. However now it advantages from extra energy, sharpened dealing with and a few new expertise options. The Mazda MX-5 Miata convertible, in the meantime, has been giving drivers inexpensive top-down thrills for over three a long time. The RF designation means it has the automobile’s obtainable retractable hardtop design. Which rear-wheel-drive sports activities automobile is the higher selection? Edmunds’ specialists in contrast them to seek out out.

PERFORMANCE AND HANDLING

Small, fun-to-drive sports activities automobiles usually prioritize dealing with confidence and poise moderately than most horsepower. As such, neither the Miata RF nor the BRZ is a powerhouse. The Mazda is supplied with a 2.0-liter inline four-cylinder engine that produces 181 horsepower and 151 lb-ft of torque. These energy figures may appear low, however the Miata RF could be very mild, weighing lower than 2,500 kilos. The Subaru BRZ packs a 2.4-liter horizontally opposed four-cylinder that cranks out 228 horsepower and 184 lb-ft. The additional energy is welcome, however this coupe weighs about 400 kilos greater than the Miata.

Acceleration for the Miata RF and BRZ is fairly fast. When geared up with the handbook transmission, the Miata RF hit 60 mph in 6.6 seconds in Edmunds’ testing. A manual-equipped BRZ was even faster: 6.1 seconds. Each automobiles provide an automated transmission. Efficiency and driver engagement suffers a bit, however every day driving in visitors definitely turns into much less of a chore.

Small sports activities automobiles are largely about agile dealing with, and the Miata RF and BRZ excel at this. You may be hard-pressed to seek out one other inexpensive trendy automobile that offers you the management, precision and predictability that these two finely tuned sports activities automobiles have. Each will deal with again roads with grace and class, however the BRZ feels a bit extra steady than the Miata RF once you drive at a really fast tempo.

Winner: Subaru BRZ

DRIVING AND COMFORT

Consolation and small sports activities automobiles usually do not go hand in hand, and the Miata RF and BRZ are no totally different. Their rides are composed and soak up most highway imperfections, however driving over bigger bumps will nonetheless offer you a superb jolt.

As for inside noise, each automobiles have so much. You would possibly anticipate the BRZ, being a coupe, to be the quieter automobile of the 2, however that is not likely the case. Tire, highway and engine noise can get fairly loud, particularly at greater speeds. The Miata RF, with its hardtop design, is not less than a bit quieter than the common soft-top Miata.

The BRZ finally pulls forward on this class by being a bit roomier. Taller drivers, particularly, will discover the BRZ’s cabin to be much less cramped than the Miata RF’s. You even get two dinky rear seats within the BRZ. They’re successfully ineffective for folks — even children — however you possibly can fold them all the way down to create extra cargo area.

Winner: Subaru BRZ

VALUE, FEATURES AND MPG

The Subaru BRZ has a beginning worth of $28,990, together with vacation spot, which is considerably lower than the Mazda Miata RF’s beginning worth of $36,015. Nevertheless, the common soft-top Miata’s beginning worth is nearly an identical to the BRZ’s.

The Miata RF is priced greater due to its energy hardtop and base Grand Touring trim that comes loaded with heated leather-based seats, adaptive headlights and a Bose audio system. The BRZ’s prime Restricted trim provides comparable options however remains to be priced considerably decrease at $31,490. However the BRZ is a coupe that may’t drop its prime, which is necessary for some patrons.

Due to sky-high gasoline costs, good gas financial system is now prime of thoughts for many individuals. The Miata RF’s mixed score of 29 mpg with the six-speed handbook transmission and 30 mpg with the six-speed automated is superb for a sports activities automobile. The BRZ’s extra highly effective engine and heavier weight harm its effectivity. It will get an EPA-estimated 22 mpg mixed with the six-speed handbook and 25 mpg mixed with the six-speed automated.

With higher gas financial system and the choice of coupe or convertible driving, the Miata RF wins this class.

Winner: Mazda Miata RF

EDMUNDS SAYS:

Except you need your hair blowing within the wind and the solar shining down in your face with the highest down, the Subaru BRZ is the winner of this comparability. Just like the Miata RF, it is enjoyable to drive and handles like a dream, but it surely’s priced decrease and provides extra room, energy and practicality.

_____

This story was supplied to The Related Press by the automotive web site Edmunds.

Michael Cantu is a contributor at Edmunds. Instagram: @michaelcartu

Associated hyperlinks:

Edmunds High Rated Sports activities Automotive for 2022